Pros 
Cons A Course Steeped in Potential, Derailed by Disrepair
Stony Falls Mini Golf in South Hadley, MA, presents a curious case. Boasting a stunning location and a layout that hints at former glory, the course currently leaves much to be desired in terms of upkeep. Reviews consistently highlight the dichotomy: a beautiful setting overshadowed by noticeable neglect. Players describe turf that is “torn up,” with “bunches and seams” adding unwanted difficulty to each hole. Several visitors reported encountering waterlogged greens and a general lack of drainage, creating unintentional hazards.
The course itself appears to be designed with straightforward, putt-only holes, but evidence suggests modifications and compromises have been made over time – one reviewer noted a blocked-up two-tiered hole filled with concrete. Despite these issues, many acknowledge the original design showed promise. It’s the feeling of “what could be” that resonates throughout many accounts, fueled by the picturesque backdrop of the Connecticut Valley and surrounding mountains. The aroma of nearby farms, while sometimes noticeable, doesn’t seem to deter visitors significantly. The water feature running through the course is a plus, providing a visual element, even if it isn't integrated into gameplay.
Here's a quick breakdown of what reviewers are saying:
- Pros: Scenic location, engaging layout (when functioning optimally), affordable price ($7 per round).
- Cons: Poor maintenance, damaged turf, drainage issues, inconsistent hole conditions, outdated signage.
- Accessibility: Excellent, with wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking, making it inclusive for all.
Family Fun & Added Attractions
While the mini golf experience itself is currently a mixed bag, Stony Falls shines as a destination for family entertainment. Beyond the 18 holes, the property offers a delightful array of complementary attractions. A small petting zoo, featuring ducks, turtles, cows, goats, llamas, and chickens, is a major draw for younger children. Coin-operated animal feeders add to the interactive experience.
Several reviewers specifically praised the close proximity to McCrays, a local ice cream parlor. A 10% discount at McCrays is offered with a Stony Falls mini golf scorecard, incentivizing a sweet treat after a round. Past visitors also enjoyed additional offerings like face painting – availability of this service is not currently consistent. This combination of activities makes Stony Falls a strong contender for a full afternoon of family fun, even if the golf itself isn't perfect.
| Attraction | Description | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Mini Golf | 18-hole putt-putt course | $7.00 |
| Petting Zoo | Small zoo with various farm animals | Included |
| Animal Feeders | Coin-operated machines for feeding animals | $0.25 - $0.50 |
| McCrays Discount | 10% off purchases with scorecard | Discounted |
| Face Painting | May be available | Varies |
A Price-Point Consideration
At $7 for a full 18 holes, Stony Falls is undeniably affordable. This reasonable price point appears to be a significant factor in visitor satisfaction, especially considering the current state of the course. Many reviewers acknowledge the shortcomings but still feel the price represents good value, particularly for families seeking a low-cost outing.
Interestingly, some older reviews mention a unique refund policy – returning your ball on the 18th hole resulted in a $1.00 refund. This practice appears to be discontinued. Current payment options include both cash and debit card. A willingness to overlook the maintenance issues seems to be tempered by the budget-friendly cost. If a pristine golfing experience is the priority, the price might not be enough to compensate for the course's condition.
Recurring Themes in the Feedback
What's clear from the customer feedback is a pattern of nostalgia and disappointment. Many visitors recall past experiences where Stony Falls held a higher standard. A common sentiment expressed is that the owners appear to have lost interest in upkeep, resulting in significant deterioration. Phrases like "zero cleaning," "zero upkeep," and "doesn't care about their mini golf" are repeatedly used.
While the location continues to be celebrated – described as “beautiful” and offering a “great way to spend a couple of hours” – the neglected state of the course is a constant concern. One reviewer, who hadn't played in 50 years, expressed a desire to return, but this optimism is juxtaposed with frustration over the current condition.
"We were here a few years ago and had a good time, but this visit shows the ownership doesn't care about their mini golf. Zero cleaning was done. I must have cleaned more then they have moving sticks and twigs off the greens." - Recent Reviewer
It's a tale of unrealized potential, where a once-great course is slowly fading due to lack of investment. Despite the frustrations, the positive atmosphere and added attractions keep drawing visitors, suggesting there's still a dedicated base hoping for a revitalization.