Pros 
Cons A Long-Standing Tradition: Hartland Golf & Arcade’s Legacy
Hartland Golf & Arcade in Ship Bottom, NJ, consistently earns high praise, currently boasting a 4.6-star rating, and it’s clear why this establishment has remained a beloved fixture for decades. Locals and tourists alike frequently mention returning every trip to the island – a testament to its enduring appeal. The course itself is consistently described as "fun" and well-maintained, known for packing a surprising amount into a relatively small space.
Many reviewers highlight the course’s challenging design, including significant elevation changes that add an extra layer of difficulty and enjoyment. Hartland doesn’t just offer a simple putt-putt experience; it curates a playful landscape that keeps players engaged. It's consistently lauded as the "best looking of the central golf courses".
Here's a quick rundown of what makes Hartland accessible:
- Wheelchair Accessible: Entrance and parking lot are both confirmed accessible.
- Family-Friendly: Specifically noted as “good for kids.”
- Convenient Parking: Offers free parking in a lot and on the street, as well as on-site parking.
- Military Discount: Active military personnel enjoy special discounts.
However, some recent commentary suggests the greens are beginning to show their age, with some reporting them as “a little tilted and uneven”. Despite this, the overwhelming sentiment remains positive.
Beyond the Greens: The Evolving Arcade
While Hartland Golf & Arcade is renowned for its miniature golf, the arcade component draws significant attention, though opinions vary. Many reviewers reminisce about arcade classics of the past – specifically lamenting the loss of the 6-player X-Men cabinet. The arcade has, like many modern entertainment centers, increasingly focused on ticket redemption games.
Dedicated arcade enthusiasts are actively offering recommendations to the owner (as evidenced by a detailed edit from July 2025!), expressing a desire for more pinball machines. The suggestions include titles like White Water, Dialed In, America’s Most Haunted, Big Bang Bar, and Mystery Castle. One reviewer even acknowledged The Big Lebowski as a potential, though potentially less family-friendly, option.
Despite the shift towards redemption games, many reviewers find the arcade to be significantly superior to the one at nearby Fantasy Island. Specifically, the cheaper prize costs are a major draw.
| Feature | Hartland Golf & Arcade | Fantasy Island Arcade |
|---|---|---|
| Pinball Machines | Limited/Few | Very Limited |
| Redemption Games | Majority | Majority |
| Prize Costs | Cheaper | More Expensive |
| Overall Quality | Generally Preferred | Less Preferred |
The Good, The Bad, and The Cash-Only
The majority of experiences at Hartland Golf & Arcade are overwhelmingly positive. Numerous patrons praise the "friendly and welcoming" staff, who appear genuinely invested in ensuring a good time for everyone. One reviewer specifically noted, “The staff is happy you are there. They want to make your experience the best it can be.” The weekly Wednesday tournament is a particular highlight, praised for its “FUN FUN FUN” atmosphere, raffles, and enticing prizes.
However, a notable, and concerning, complaint revolves around rude employee behavior. One reviewer explicitly states they "would not go here ever again" due to insults and trouble encountered on the course. This isolated incident stands in stark contrast to the numerous positive interactions reported by others.
It's also important to note a practical detail: Hartland Golf & Arcade operates on a cash-only basis. This can be a point of inconvenience for some, so planning ahead is advisable. They do offer souvenir custom golf balls for purchase, a popular memento of the experience.
A Weekly Highlight: Wednesday Tournaments and Dedicated Players
Dedicated players rave about the Wednesday tournament at Hartland Golf & Arcade. The event is clearly a cornerstone of the community, drawing repeat visitors who attend “several times a week.” The tournaments aren’t just about the game itself; they are social events, complete with raffles and compelling prizes.
These tournaments showcase Hartland’s commitment to building a loyal customer base and fostering a sense of community around the game of miniature golf. The consistent positive feedback about this weekly event underscores the value of engaging experiences beyond simply offering a well-maintained course. One player’s enthusiasm encapsulates this perfectly: “5 stars plus. They go all out for the weekly Wednesday tournament.”