Pros 
Cons A Scenic Escape: The Ups and Downs of Settlers Mill
Settlers Mill of Oshkosh consistently scores a respectable 4.3 stars, and for good reason. Many visitors praise the course’s aesthetics and upkeep. It clearly strives for a presentable experience. The beautiful water features and carefully maintained grounds are common highlights in reviews. This isn’t a flashy, modern mini golf experience; it’s described as a “classic course” with “esthetically pleasing” qualities. Several reviewers specifically mention the challenging, yet accessible, nature of the holes – offering a balance for both casual players and self-proclaimed “mini golf enthusiasts.”
Here’s a quick rundown of what players seem to appreciate:
- Visually Appealing: Water features, hills, and generally well-maintained landscaping.
- Difficulty Balance: Holes provide a challenge without being impossible to navigate.
- Cleanliness: Both the course and the clubhouse receive positive remarks regarding cleanliness.
- Family Friendly: Often mentioned as a good activity for families and dates.
However, the experience isn’t without its drawbacks, and some visitors feel the course relies heavily on luck rather than skill.
The Price of Play & Payment Quirks
The cost to play a round is around $11 per golfer, which some consider a little high. While not exorbitant, it’s worth noting, especially considering some of the complaints regarding course design. Settlers Mill does offer weekday specials to help lower the price.
Payments are an area that generates considerable frustration. While the location accepts debit cards and NFC mobile payments, it does not accept credit cards. This forces customers to utilize an on-site ATM – complete with a $3 usage fee. This feels… inconvenient, to say the least, particularly when combined with reports of double charges on debit card transactions.
Here’s a breakdown of the payment situation:
| Payment Method | Accepted? | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Credit Cards | No | |
| Debit Cards | Yes | Potential for double charging |
| NFC Mobile Payments | Yes | |
| Cash | Likely | (Not explicitly stated, but assumed) |
| On-Site ATM | Yes | $3 usage fee |
Concerns Regarding Safety & Customer Service
The most concerning reviews center around potential safety hazards and problematic customer service. One reviewer explicitly stated the course was “dangerous,” citing conditions where people could “fall or get injured." This is a serious accusation and warrants attention. Other complaints include a double charge for tokens, which the manager allegedly refused to rectify.
These issues cast a shadow over the positive aspects of the course. Proactive maintenance and a more responsive, responsible approach to customer issues are crucial for Settlers Mill’s reputation.
Here’s a summary of the major issues:
- Safety Hazards: Reports of conditions potentially leading to falls or injuries.
- Billing Errors: Double charges for tokens, with unhelpful manager response.
- Lack of Accountability: Some customers feel the management is unwilling to take responsibility for issues.
- Basic Amenities: Reports of “no running water” due to “neglect”.
Noise & Overall Playability – A Mixed Bag
The course's location directly on the highway presents a significant noise issue. Several reviewers mention the distracting traffic sound. While the course itself is described as “beautiful,” this constant background noise detracts from the overall experience.
Beyond the noise, opinions on the actual gameplay are divided. While some find the course “challenging” and a good test of skill, others feel it lacks thoughtful design. The complaint that most holes depend more on luck than skill is a recurring theme. This leads to a lack of replay value, as the gameplay feels repetitive and unpredictable.
To put it bluntly:
“There is almost no thought to any hole. Most holes require much more luck than skill and are boring and repetitive.”
Despite the criticisms, the provided gear is considered “decent and manageable,” and many still report having “a great time” with family and friends. However, it's clear that Settlers Mill of Oshkosh could benefit from addressing the safety concerns, improving payment options/transparency, and potentially re-evaluating the course's design for a more skill-based and rewarding experience.