Pros 
Cons A Hole-in-One Experience: What Players are Saying About Puttery NYC
Puttery, the mini golf destination located at 446 W 14th St in Manhattan, is quickly gaining a reputation as the place to be for a unique and fun night out. Boasting a 4.40 rating, it's drawing crowds with its high-tech courses, lively atmosphere, and surprisingly delicious food and drink options. But what exactly are people saying about their experiences? Let’s dive into the buzz surrounding this trendy spot.
The excitement surrounding Puttery isn’t just about the golf; it’s about the full package. Many reviewers highlight the welcoming atmosphere and exceptional staff. Several individuals specifically mentioned positive interactions: Ari at the front desk receiving praise for a warm welcome, Payton being lauded for attentiveness and friendliness, Nuzhaat the bartender being described as “gracious” and providing great service, and Jada for her dedication to ensuring a smooth and enjoyable golfing experience, as well as Edely’s assistance to walk-ins. Beyond individual shoutouts, there’s a consistent theme of politeness and accommodation from the staff. One team even used Puttery for a staff appreciation event, specifically citing the seamless booking process and helpfulness as key factors in their enjoyment.
- Location Perks: Situated in Manhattan, Puttery is easily accessible, though street parking is paid and can be tricky to find.
- Accessibility: The venue is wheelchair accessible, which is a significant plus for inclusivity.
- Payment Options: Puttery accepts all major forms of payment, including credit cards, debit cards, and mobile payments like NFC.
- Additional Amenities: Beyond the golf, guests can enjoy food from the restaurant, restrooms, and even catch a comedy show at the Highline Comedy club on-site!
Course Design and Gameplay: More Than Just a Putt
The miniature golf at Puttery isn't your childhood boardwalk experience. Reviewers consistently mention the creative and challenging course designs. While the courses are only 9 holes each, don’t underestimate the difficulty! Some players found the holes "a lil tough," adding to the excitement. One reviewer, a self-proclaimed mini-golf connoisseur, claimed Puttery is their “favorite” in the city, and worth the wait if you had heard earlier reports of disorganization. They specifically recommend experiencing both courses available. A standout mention came from a player who praised Dion for recommending the “green jacket” and alerting them to the “fire shrimp” – hinting at potential course-specific challenges or features.
Here’s a breakdown of common feedback on the courses themselves:
| Feature | Feedback |
|---|---|
| Difficulty | Challenging, good for experienced and novice players |
| Length | Relatively short (9 holes), makes for a quick game |
| Design | Creative, themed, immersive. One course is called "Museum" |
| Pace | Can feel rushed, especially when busy |
Beyond the Green: Food, Drinks, and Entertainment
Puttery is positioning itself as a multi-entertainment destination. The on-site restaurant and bar receive frequent praise. Several reviews highlight the quality of the food, with one individual specifically raving about the ribs. The bar is a popular spot for pre- or post-golf drinks, and the bartender, Nuzhaat, received special recognition for attentive service and delicious offerings.
But the fun doesn't stop there. The inclusion of Highline Comedy adds another layer of entertainment. Reviewers enjoyed the “hilarious” comedians and the overall “great vibe” of the comedy show, noting it contributes to a complete outing. The availability of both alcoholic and non-alcoholic beverage options also contributes to its broad appeal.
- Average Cost: A round for two people on both courses runs approximately $100, making it a reasonably priced evening out for the experience offered.
- Menu Variety: The restaurant offers a range of options beyond just quick bites.
- Live Entertainment: Regularly scheduled comedy shows provide entertainment beyond the golf itself.
Areas for Improvement: Things to Consider
Despite the overwhelmingly positive feedback, a few recurring themes suggest areas where Puttery could improve. Some players mentioned feeling rushed, especially on busy nights, with wait times between holes. The temperature in the third floor was noted as a concern. While the venue accommodates wheelchair access, further refinement in guest flow experiences might improve the inclusivity for all demographics.
While the enthusiastic response is largely positive, prospective players should be aware of these points:
- Potential Crowds: Bookings are recommended to avoid long wait times, particularly on weekends.
- Temperature Control: Be prepared for potential temperature variations within the venue.
- Course Time: The 9-hole format is fun but can feel brief, so consider playing both courses.
- Noise Levels: As a lively entertainment venue, expect a potentially loud atmosphere.
Overall, Puttery NYC seems to be making waves in the New York City entertainment scene, offering a unique blend of playful competition, delicious food and drinks, and live entertainment. While a few minor adjustments could enhance the experience, the overwhelming consensus suggests it's a hole-in-one destination for a fun night out.