Pros 
Cons A Charming Escape: The Atmosphere of Forsythe Miniature Golf
Forsythe Miniature Golf in Carnegie, PA, isn’t just a game; it's an experience. Regularly earning a stellar 4.7-star rating, this miniature golf course captivates visitors with its unique blend of old-school charm and modern appeal. Nestled under a flourishing canopy of trees and illuminated by enchanting string lights, the course provides a beautifully shaded and aesthetically pleasing environment. Many reviewers specifically mention the delightful ambiance, noting its suitability for both romantic dates and family outings.
Beyond the visual appeal, the setting provides little glimpses of nature. Frequent visitors have even reported sightings of the owners’ chickens roaming nearby and playful squirrels darting through the trees, adding to the whimsical atmosphere. It's the kind of place that encourages lingering, and thankfully, ample seating is available. While autumnal visits may require navigating fallen leaves, which can slightly impact ball roll, most agree this is a minor inconvenience easily overlooked given the overall picturesque setting. The course also incorporates some stairs, for anyone with mobility concerns.
Challenges and Gameplay: A Test of Skill (and Patience!)
The course itself strikes a balance between fun and challenge. Forsythe Miniature Golf thoughtfully designs its holes, making the most of its space with inventive and often unexpected obstacles. Several reviewers highlight the uniqueness of the holes, stating they haven't encountered similar designs elsewhere.
However, be prepared for a bit of a challenge! A recurring theme in reviews is the presence of uphill holes. While creative, these can be frustrating as balls often roll back down, leading to extra attempts and potential delays. Some players have mentioned inconsistencies in the greens’ speed, adding another layer of difficulty.
Here’s a quick breakdown of gameplay concerns:
- Uphill Struggles: Dominant throughout the back nine, these holes can slow down progress.
- Green Inconsistency: Uneven surfaces can lead to unpredictable ball behavior.
- Crowd Impact: Higher traffic, particularly Saturday evenings, contributes to wait times between holes.
- Potential Frustration: Unique holes, while engaging, may sometimes feel unrewarding.
Despite these minor caveats, the course appears skillfully laid out and provides a memorable experience for players of most skill levels.
The Sweetest Hole-in-One: Ice Cream Sensations
Forget typical concession stand fare. A major highlight of Forsythe Miniature Golf, consistently praised by visitors, is its handcrafted ice cream sandwiches. The homemade options, available in a staggering 12 varieties, seem to be a game-changer.
Reviewers rave about flavors like black cherry crumble and pumpkin spice paired with spiced ginger cookies, and the classic Dirt Cup and root beer float are popular choices as well. This isn’t just an add-on; it’s a destination within a destination.
Here's what sets their ice cream apart:
- Variety: 12 unique sandwich combinations to choose from.
- Homemade: Everything is made fresh on-site.
- Dietary Options: Gluten-free cookies and dairy-free ice cream cater to various needs.
- Exceptional Quality: Repeatedly described as “the best ice cream sandwiches of all time.”
Many visitors specifically recommend not skipping the ice cream, suggesting it’s an integral part of the Forsythe experience.
Practicalities & Perks: Planning Your Visit
Forsythe Miniature Golf offers several conveniences for visitors. The course conveniently accepts debit cards and NFC mobile payments, though credit cards are not currently accepted. Restrooms are available onsite. The facility operates seasonally with the following hours:
| Day | Hours |
|---|---|
| Friday | 11 AM – 9:30 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Saturday | 11 AM – 9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 12 PM – 9:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM – 9:30 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM – 9:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM – 9:30 PM |
Beyond the gameplay and delicious treats, Forsythe Miniature Golf also offers a fun “Plinko” game at the end, giving patrons a chance to win a free game. Scorecards are provided via helpful clipboards. The family-friendly atmosphere makes it suitable for all ages, and it's clear the owners care about creating a welcoming and enjoyable environment for their guests.